10 common sources of stress faced by early-career researchers
One aspect of academia that strikes me the most is the number of academics, especially early-career scientists, who struggle with mental health issues such as anxiety, uncontrollable stress, panic attacks, depression, or burnout.
Â
Iâve also experienced mentally challenging times during my academic career. These periods were tough but have helped me understand why academia can be a significant source of stress and what we can do to manage this stress and navigate our academic lives in the most fulfilling and meaningful way.
Â
Thatâs why I would like to discuss the topic of mental health with you.
Â
In todayâs newsletter, I will focus on raising awareness on two critical aspects: key statistics related to mental health during a PhD, and the primary sources of stress during a PhD.
Â
My aim for today? To help you realize that youâre not alone, and that if you face high levels of stress or struggle with your mental health, itâs largely due to the environment itself (academia) which significantly contributes to this stress.
Â
Yes, that also means you didnât do anything wrong.
Â
Highlighting these issues is crucial, but at NextMinds, we also love to find solutions and provide tools to help you navigate academia! Therefore, the next newsletter will focus on tools and strategies you can implement to keep stress levels manageable and make your PhD journey as healthy and fulfilling as possible.
Mental Health of PhD Students in the Netherlands: Key Statistics
We often hear that many PhD students struggle during their PhD journey, but what are the real numbers?
Â
I would like to share with you some statistics published in 2021 by the PhD Network Netherlands (PNN). This data is based on a survey of more than 1,600 respondents, providing a comprehensive look at the mental health of PhD students in the Netherlands.
Â
Note: I chose to focus on statistics from the Netherlands because I am most familiar with this country, and many of you work in Dutch institutions. However, similar trends are seen in other countries and reports.
Â
Some key statistics:
đ¸ Increased risk of mental health problems: 47% of PhD candidates in the Netherlands are at an increased risk. This risk is higher among international PhD students, with 56% facing increased mental health issues.
đ¸ Work pressure: nearly 60% of PhD candidates experience high or too high work pressure.
đ¸ Overtime work: 63% of PhD students work more hours than stated in their contracts, averaging 4.4 extra hours per week.
đ¸ Burnout symptoms: 39% of PhD students exhibit severe symptoms of burnout. This proportion is higher among scholarship recipients (44%) and international students (45%).
đ¸ Concerns about completion: in total, 47% of PhD students are either unsure about finishing on time (20%) or donât think they will finish on time (27%).
đ¸ Considering quitting: 42% of PhD candidates have considered quitting their PhD. Common reasons include doubts about academia, lack of enjoyment, self-doubt, supervisory issues, and mental health problems.
You can download the full report here and read a summary of the survey results here.
Â
Why do I share with you these numbers?
Â
These statistics seem alarming to me and I want to raise awareness. Academia, and particularly the PhD trajectory, presents unique challenges that contribute to high-stress levels among early-career scientists and academics.
Â
What does this mean?
đ¸ You’re not alone: a lot of PhD students face similar struggles.
đ¸ Systemic issues: the environment itself contributes significantly to this stress (in other words: no, itâs not your fault)
Â
Letâs discuss the specific sources of stress for PhD students in more detail.
Sources of Stress for PhD Students
Credits: this list of stressors has been inspired by Dr. Zoe Ayres, who does an excellent job raising awareness about PhD mental health.
Â
#1 | Imposter Syndrome
Doing a PhD means being surrounded by smart colleagues. Many PhD students feel they are not as competent or intelligent as their colleagues, attributing their success to luck rather than ability. This sense of self-doubt can lead to chronic stress and anxiety.
I remember having a lot of imposter syndrome during my PhD. My experiments weren’t working, I couldn’t figure out why they weren’t working. I felt that many of my colleagues were much smarter than me. Later I understood that I wasn’t dumb (I think đ ), but that a PhD is also very much a matter of luck.
Â
#2 | First-Time Failing
The rigorous demands of doctoral programs often mean encountering significant academic challenges and, sometimes, failure for the first time. This can be a difficult adjustment for those who have previously excelled during their studies.
Before I started my PhD, the only thing I had failed was my first attempt at getting my driving licence. I had never failed a test or exam before. Spending the first 2-3 years of my PhD with a lot of failed experiments was a real challenge – and learning curve – for me.
(I failed my driving test because I was driving on the speed track of the motorway at 60 km/h. But that’s a story for another time).
Â
#3 | Academic Culture of Overwork
The expectation to work long hours is ingrained in the academic culture. The pressure to produce results and the lack of work-life balance are major contributors to stress and burnout. Overwork doesn’t leave enough space for activities that favour a healthy mental well-being (enough sleep, healthy food, social moments, physical exercise, etc.).
Â
#4 | Relationship with Supervisor
The dynamic between PhD students and their supervisors can greatly impact their experience. A great supervisor and mentor will be an invaluable support to navigate the PhD journey. On the other hand, poor communication with the supervisor, micromanagement, lack of support, or mismatched expectations can create a stressful working environment.
Â
#5 | No More Tick-Boxes
During bachelorâs and masterâs studies, including internships, deadlines and expectations for assignments are usually clearly defined. Feedback from supervisors or teachers is also common.
PhD programs, however, lack clear milestones and frequent feedback, making it difficult for students to gauge their progress and leading to uncertainty and stress.
Â
#6 | Financial Concerns
Many PhD students face financial instability due to insufficient funding, leading to additional stress about meeting living expenses and managing student debt.
Financial concerns can also be related to the fact that PhD students have to pay conference registration fees in advance and wait a few weeks for reimbursement from their host institution.
Â
#7 | Competitive Landscape
Academia is a competitive environment. There is competition at all academic levels, even if it is unspoken. This competition can be stimulating, but it can also create a high-pressure environment in which PhD students feel a constant need to prove their worth.
Â
#8 | Publication Pressure
The need to publish âenoughâ (i.e., a specific number of scientific articles) and in relatively high-impact journals is a significant source of stress. The pressure to contribute original research can lead to feelings of inadequacy and anxiety.
Â
#9 | Feeling of Isolation
Doctoral research can be a solitary endeavour, leading to feelings of isolation. Often PhD students don’t realise that although they are working in a group and can help each other, they are often the only candidate working on their project. This can be very frustrating if the project doesn’t go as planned.
Â
#10 | “Normalization” of Struggles
There is a weird tendency to view stress and depression as normal parts of the PhD experience. But itâs not! This normalization prevents students from seeking the help they need and perpetuates a culture of silent suffering.
Interested in receiving insights, tips and tools directly in your inbox? Sign up for the NextMinds Newsletter!